9. Chunky Monkey

What is it about banana and walnuts that go so well together? We're pretty sure they're soul mates destined to be together. In the freezer. With plenty of fudge chunks.

8. Americone Dream

Do you dream in caramel swirls? Us, too. Caramel and waffle cone dreams come true in this iconic pint.

7. Phish Food

Fans flocked to pints of Phish Food like jam ban fans to a Phish concert this year. Was it the marshmallow swirls or the fudge fish that did it? We may never know.

6. The Tonight Dough

Two kinds of ice cream, two kinds of cookie dough, and one epic swirl. What else could a dough lover need?

5. Chocolate Fudge Brownie

The chocolatiest chocolate that's ever chocolated. Chocolate lovers, take note.

4. Strawberry Cheesecake

Would it be too cheesy if we said this flavor is berry berry extraordinary? Yeah, it definitely would be.

3. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Holding steady at #3, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough has been a fan fave ever since an anonymous fan suggested it back in 1984. That's 39 years of dough-lighting fans!

2. Cherry Garcia

When you make a sundae with Cherry Garcia, do you still add a cherry on top? Of course you do, because there's no such thing as too many cherries.

1. Half Baked

Why have just one ice cream flavor when you could have two? Fans' undying love for Half Baked proves that when you mix Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough and Chocolate Fudge Brownie, the result is pure magic.

How did 2023 compare to 2022? Read Ben & Jerry's 2022's most popular flavors.