Another point of view

Aseptic packaging won't save fluid milk

The author offers an opposing point of view to the merits of fluid milk in aseptic packages.

September 25, 2012
/ Print / Reprints /
/ Text Size+

Editor's note: Daryl J. Orris is the president and CEO of The Ice Cream Bar Inc. He wrote this opinion in response to the editorial "Can technology save fluid milk?" by Dairy Foods editor-in-chief Jim Carper.

The recent editorial by Jim Carper, Dairy Foods chief editor asked the question: Can technology save fluid milk?

My response to the question is most emphatic: The worst thing that could ever happen to fluid milk is to use aseptic packaging.

Why? Because the dairy industry would lose those great big electronic display cases that now adorn over 10,000 Class A grocery stores in the United States. And when you add in independents and convenience stores, too, the damage to the industry would be incalculable.

Imagine shelf-stable commodity milk that requires no refrigeration, no lights and no cool-to-the-touch when the consumer picks up her intended purchase. All of that history and consumer conditioning is lost, as would be aseptically packaged milk, lost in the aisles among 10,000 to 50,000 other SKUs.

I have lived in Hong Kong and toured throughout China. No fancy electronic refrigerated displays for dairy products there, and not much consumption of fluid milk either. All fluid milk products were shelf-stable, lost within the aisles of the store; some merchandised with the cereal aisle, some in the baking aisle and some on a kiosk. In many cases, they were placed anywhere, including on a back wall. Other dairy products were drowning in spot coolers. Imagine that scenario in the United States.

It reminds me of when the Pillsbury Co. had can stops and merchandising materials that called out its different SKUs for its refrigerated dough products. They expanded it into complex display sets in every American Class A grocery store. Then when private-label and competitive products began to invade the section, Pillsbury complained about foreign products that pirated their shelf space. Eventually retailers figured it out: they had been providing a free display to them for years. The loss was catastrophic for Pillsbury, one that they could not recoup from.

A catastrophe looms large if producers’ turn to aseptic packaging and retailers ultimately end indirectly supporting dairy with their costly dedicated refrigerated case. The loss in fluid milk sales would lower the cost of milk for companies like mine who buy milk. But the loss to the dairy industry as a whole would end small producer fresh milk and favor large factory dairies that would ultimately end, or to a great degree control them, and affect commodity prices as well. The small farm dairy producers and local dairies would be the victims of this debacle.

It will be a sad day when aseptic packaging becomes the norm for fluid milk. It will forever change the small producer dairy industry and the industry as a whole – not for the better, but for the worse.

I would be remiss if I didn’t state that there is a light at the end of the tunnel: exports. Aseptic packaging makes the exporting of fluid milk a snap. We know that there are huge markets that would want high quality U.S. fluid milk and cream, but the cost is the inevitable loss of U.S. fluid milk sales because of the loss of the refrigerated case. It’s a bird in the hand and the one in the bush scenario. The one in the bush is growing demand for quality U.S. dairy products. The one in the hand is the impact on fluid milk sales with aseptic packaging with retailers rescinding the expense of refrigerated merchandising in favor of the shelf.

Did you enjoy this article? Click here to subscribe to Dairy Foods Magazine. 
You must login or register in order to post a comment.



Image Galleries

Velvet Ice Cream Co., Utica, Ohio

Velvet Ice Cream built its reputation on making premium products that adhere to the standard of identity for ice cream. Its lines consist of premium, all natural, churned (low-fat), no sugar added, novelties, sherbet (in cups and in push-up tubes) and a controlled ice cream brand for grocery store customers.


This photo gallery contains additional, unpublished photos of dairy processing facilities featured in Dairy Foods magazine. To view more Behind the Scenes galleries go to our archives page!

11/18/14 2:00 pm EST

Product Inspection Fundamentals for the Dairy Industry

On Demand Consolidation in the dairy industry is raising the bar on innovation and driving efficiencies to ensure competitiveness. One area often overlooked is the role that the right product inspection program can play in supporting the organization’s overall business goals and protecting brand reputation. Drawing on best practices in metal detection, X-ray inspection and checkweighing, this session will cover criteria to help determine the right technologies to employ for a given product and packaging type for high-value, perishable dairy products.

Dairy Foods Magazine

df december 2014

2014 December

Dannon is our Processor of the Year, plus much more!

Table Of Contents Subscribe

Santa's treats

Which dairy food are you most likely to leave out for Santa Claus?
View Results Poll Archive


Tharp & Young on Ice Cream: An Encyclopedic Guide to Ice Cream Science and Technology

An at once an all-inclusive guide to the meaning of hundreds of technical terms and ideas needed for ice cream manufacturing, as well as a practical introduction to the ingredients, freezing methods, flavoring, and packaging of ice cream, sherbet, sorbet, gelato, frozen yogurts, novelties and many other kinds of frozen desserts.

More Products

Clear Seas Research

Clear Seas ResearchWith access to over one million professionals and more than 60 industry-specific publications, Clear Seas Research offers relevant insights from those who know your industry best. Let us customize a market research solution that exceeds your marketing goals.


Facebook logo 40px 2-12-13 Twitter logo 40px 2-12-13  YouTube logo 40px 2-12-13  LinkedIn logo 40px 2-12-13google plus

Dairy Foods Buyers Guide

cover df july 2013Resource for buyers in the dairy processing industry to find information on the leading suppliers and manufacturers.

Find Ingredients, Equipment, Distribution, R&D and More.

Start Your Search Today.